12 Most Pressing Reasons Social Media Must Die
Social Media can certainly be credited for some amazing social good and business achievements during past years including the sponsoring of regime change in some countries, mass awareness of public issues and fundraising activities for charities. However, the public’s fixation on “Social Media” has also created a national distraction that has limited the individual, businesses and our society in general.
At the very least, it’s spawned a series of personal pet peeves that makes me want give it a lethal injection. So I submit for your consideration, my 12 most pressing reasons Social Media must die.
1. The ridiculous job titles
Social Media has single handily spawned a new breed of experts, ninjas, gurus and grand imperial wizards which mean nothing but authorized chatter-boxes. This alone should be enough reason to kill it but we’ll continue.
2. Lost sight of profit
Social Media has made millions for start-ups and entrepreneurs but muddied the waters on generating profit for the rest our businesses. Too much of Social Media’s focus has been on engagement for the sake of engagement with no one willing to take responsibility for the business’s profit. This has to stop.
3. Blurred the definition of ROI
ROI = Return on Investment, which before Social Media became the be-all-and-end-all of the business psyche, meant the net dollars left over when a tactic’s expenses were subtracted from the revenue that it generated. Yet most marketers are focused on redefining ROI to mean a number of tweets, a number of followers or other such “metrics” in an attempt to justify their inability to link their social engagement with measurable revenue.
4. Oh, the buzzwords
Authentic. Holistic. Transparency. Trust. While it’s generally the improper use of these words that annoys me, the overuse of them has certainly annoyed enough people to drop out of social chatter altogether.
5. Redefined personal relationships
The very nature of friendships seems to have been modified by decreasing the value of “depth” in human connections. People boast their undying love for others that they’ve never met face to face across the digital airwaves on an increasingly frequent basis. What does that say about those we do engage in person?!
6. Klout
The simple fact that Social Media has allowed businesses such as Klout (and others) to establish false perceptions of people’s influence and impact on our community has added “Social Media” to the Digital Most Wanted list. When we start making judgment calls about a person’s ability based on gamified digital engagements, we’re heading down the wrong path.
7. Too many rainbows and cats
Men crying over double rainbows or toilet-flushing cats may be fine for a momentary diversions but frankly, too much of the user generated content distributed through Social Media is such drivel and too little of it is about changing the world for the better.
8. Increasing national obesity levels
Social Media cannot be blamed for the fact that the American population is one of the heaviest in the world, but it has certainly played an active role is propelling the gross-weight of the US to new heights, er, pounds.
9. Diminished the value of a handshake
A retweet is commonly referred to as having the equivalent value of a handshake today; a truly sad state of affairs. The value of a strong handshake while looking your contact in the eye conveys more about you and your character than a lazy retweet.
10. Oversharing
Propelled by social networks, oversharing has become so accepted in our society that it’s almost expected. We’re disappointed when people don’t share the frequency of their cat’s bowel movements or the number of times they visit a Starbucks. Mundane personal habits have become fodder for national news.
11. Destroying the concept of privacy
Aside of the oversharing point above, Social Media has lowered our expectations of privacy. In fact, most willingly accept lower privacy settings in favor of increased social sharing. How many of you blindly check “terms of use” without reading them? Or agreed to “grant access” to Facebook to download apps, play games or converge social networks?
12. Farmville
Nielsen recently reported that Facebook & Farmville represent 1/3 of the average Web surfer’s online time! If only 10% of those people spent that free time growing real vegetables and raising real livestock we’d effectively eliminate world hunger.
In all seriousness, the real point here is that while it was a necessary step in the evolution of communication, the public’s fixation on “Social Media” as an independent entity has stifled our creativity and innovation towards “what’s next”. We’re not seeing the forest for the trees folks. When we finally drop the title and embrace Social Media for what it is: digital word of mouth, we’ll be free to evolve to whatever is next in human and business communications.
Can I get an AMEN?
Sam, I can't believe I missed this brilliant post back in November. But I have a good reason. I had to stop my twitter monitoring and news feed reading for a bit so I could catch up on work. Too much info makes me feel overwhelmed and under-accomplished. Maybe that's just me. Anyway...I think this is one of the best posts of 2011, hands down. Everything I wish I could have said if I was as eloquent as you. :-) Oversharing by my "friends" has driven me to distraction!
AMEN!
watch this to see how to spent our time even better - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ht4qiDRZE8
You brought up some great points and some grim ones. In some cases, social media has become nothing more than a playground for adults with too much time on their hands. Do we really need to see a picture of your dog every time they return from the vet? Social media has just gotten too "noisy." People have forgotten simple good manners. You can make a good, solid networking connection using the social media sites if you really get focused and serious. And no, don't tell me you love me on the first handshake, I mean retweet!
MarthaGiffen I don't see an issue with social channels being used for socializing (rather than pure business connections). The tools are only what we make of them. And too few have blinders on.
Nice article, good luck
OMG cannot stand Farmville. Yeah, it's gotta die. AMEN.
PRbySweetTooth I have no issue if someone wants to waste their day on it. It's their need to send me alert after alert requesting "help to produce more manure for their garden" that has me seeing red!
Hah, definitely get annoyed with the titles and over-used buzzwords, and I have a recent 12Most post poking fun at Klout (although I think it's here to stay). I also got a chuckle at men crying at rainbows...even though I'm a guy who likes a good photography post ;)
dbvickery Thanks for stoping by. Sadly Klout will be around for a while. Social Media addicts are like Sheep...they will follow others over a cliff.
I think Empire Avenue should die too. Along with MySpace.
Fun post. Obviously, I know you were kidding a bit. :-)
Biebert Arguements were certainly tongue-in-cheek, however, the point wasn't. The term "Social Media" has become an obstacle for many and preventing many businesses from truly understanding what the concept of social can do across the entire organization.
Oh wait, I actually thought this was a joke until I read some of the comments.
craigbeebe I NEVER joke...said the Rabbi to the Priest as they entered a bar.....
What the heck. two years of tweeting. A Social media agency planned to launch in the next 7 hours and I land on a 12most post telling me my entrerpeneurial dream is dead.
Back to MySpace, the telegraph, smoke signals and my African drums. Heretic Sam :)
hey Kenny... he does have a point.... Besides, Sam is one of the greatest, a pioneer, a real trail blazer. - Didi I just break reason #5 ?
LewisPoretz Lewis, you forgot "Guru" in that list.....
Grit08 Letter-writing is the new "social media" my dear friend.
You raise some intersting points, espically the last one about Farmville. Like all things there needs to be a balance. Many people seem to use Social Media as a blunt insturment, but it is most useful when used in short bursts with precision. It should be an addition to our daily routines, not the sum of them.
My latest conversation: Building Community Brick By Brick
susansilver I like your analogy of Social Media being used as a blunt instrument instead of a precision instrument. I may use that as focus of my next post. Thanks. Checks-in-the-mail.
So Sam, how do you REALLY feel?
BruceSallan Slightly tired this morning Bruce, but otherwise fine. Thanks for asking.
samfiorella Glad I just finished a jog to hop on my comp! : ) Loved this post...really valid points, but I don't see the trend going back to hopscotch in the yard and home telephones anytime soon. Do you think there will be a backlash in the future, i.e. folks shutting off their electronics and breathing some fresh air or having a non-virtual meeting?
DixieLil Hmmm...whenever our society moves to an extreme, there's always some backlash and a "return to basics" movement. I agree that we'll not see kids on the streets playing street-hockey or skipping rope all day like when we were kids but some return to non-digital living will become in vogue again. Just like the current movement towards (back to) "organic fruits & vegetables" (if you believe there can ever be such a thing)
samfiorellaDixieLil And using print communications to really make your business stand out since no one else is doing it!
PaulBiedermannsamfiorellaDixieLil lol, love this point Paul.
My latest conversation: Building Community Brick By Brick
I agree on the whole Farmville thing. However, do you really think social media has contributed to the obesity issue? I know you're being sort of snarky about some of these, but I wondered if you had any stats to back that up. Sadly, it does seem a bit more active than watching television.
There certainly are annoyances that come with social media. However, I think we all can agree that the positives far outweigh the negatives. And, of course, it's not going anywhere.
I do wish you had added Mark Zuckerberg as one of your reasons. He alone makes me dislike social media. I'm not sure what it is about that kid...
My latest conversation: Telling the Human Side of the Story
profkrg Yes, this is a somewhat tongue-in-cheek commentary but I do believe that SM has contributed to general poor physical health including obesity. SM is becoming an addiction for many, which means more time spent sitting at a computer and less time out and about.
Zuckerberg is annoying but I can't fault a man for creating a business and making money from it. A ton of money. I look to the sheep who blindly follow. The only power Zuckerberg or Facebook has over us is the what we give it.
Truth serum. Another great post, samfiorella
My latest conversation: Discover How to Stop Saying "um" and "uh" in Your Conversation
westfallonline Thanks, but truth is only as good as those willing to listen. .









[...] 12 Most Pressing Reasons Social Media Must Die | Sam Fiorella shocks us with the 12 Most Pressing Reasons Social Media Must Die… Source: 12most.com [...]
[...] is often accused of being a broadcast network. That is because we have a tendency to use social media as blunt tools and not as precise instruments.If you really want to get more Twitter followers you need to focus [...]