About Me
advertisement

12 Most Compelling Reasons to Homeschool Your Children

12 Most Compelling Reasons to Homeschool Your Children

I’ve been a public school educator and administrator for more than a decade, so you may be surprised that when parents ask for my advice about education, I often suggest they allow their children to leave school. Education reform is happening today, but it’s slow and often ineffective. Parents need to do what is in the best interest of their children, right now.

For some this means working hard with a school to adapt to meet a child’s needs. But many schools are rigid and don’t believe students are entitled to a customized learning experience. For these parents the best option is often to leave school behind and empower children with the freedom to learn what they want in the way that is best for them.

Here are the twelve most compelling reasons for leaving school behind if your child is not finding success and happiness there.

1. Learning is customized not standardized

•  In school learning is standardized to what someone else says is best.
•  At home learning is customized to what the child and parent feel is best.

2. Associate with those you enjoy rather than those who share your birth year

•  In school students are grouped by date of manufacture.
•  At home children can choose to be with those whose company they enjoy.

3. Freedom to learn with their tools

•  In school students are often banned from using they tools they love to learn with — such as a cell phone.
•  At home children can learn with the tools they choose. For many children technology open doors that schools slam shut.

4. Socialize with those who share your passions not just your zip code

•  In school students have little opportunity to socialize and even when they do it is generally confined to those with whom they’ve been grouped with by year and geography.
•  At home children have the opportunity to socialize and make global connections with others of any age who share their talents, passions, and interests.

5. Real life measures are better than bubble tests

•  In school we measure students success with bubble tests and response to prompts.
•  At home we measure success by what children accomplish that matters to them. Some teens like Leah Miller have developed their own personal success plan (see hers here). She sets her goals and then assesses her success in meeting them.

6. Don’t just read about doing stuff. Do stuff!

•  In school students are forced to sit at desks all day reading and answering questions about stuff other people do.
•  At home children don’t need to spend their time reading and writing about what other people do. They can go do stuff.

7. Travel when you want

•  In school they tell you when to go on vacation and families hop off to crowded destinations together.
•  At home families can decide when travelling works best for them and also get better rates.

8. You are more than a number

•  In school the only things students have to show for their work are numbers and graphs known as report cards, transcripts, or data reports.
•  At home children often put together meaningful portfolios that can be reflected upon and powerfully capture and celebrate learning. This can be done at school, but it rarely happens as little time is left for assessment and reflection after testing and test prep.

9. Do work you value

•  In school students do work someone else wants for someone else’s purpose.
•  At home children can engage in meaningful work for reasons they determine are important.

10. Independence is valued over dependence

•  In school students are dependent on others to tell them what to do and when. They spend their time as compliant workers and are discouraged from questioning authority.
•  At home children are encouraged to explore, discover, and develop their own passions and talents and given the freedom to work deeply in these areas. They know how to learn independently because they are interested, not because they are told to do something.

11. You don’t have to waste learning time with standardized tests

•  In school students and their teachers are spending a large percentage of their time preparing for tests and testing even though test have little to no role in real life. My last test was more than a decade ago. How about you?
•  At home children have the freedom to enjoy learning without the burden or stress of testing. Although many children and parents have been trained to believe testing is a necessary evil in school kids who have the freedom to learn without testing are doing just fine and exploring their passions as grown unschooler Kate Fridkis explains in her article that reveals how we can learn successfully without testing.

12. No more meaningless worksheets and reports

•  In school students often complain they are forced to do meaningless worksheets and reports that have no real purpose or audience. In fact these worksheets and reports often actually suck the joy out of learning. Think about it. When was the last time you read a great book and thought, “Wow! I want to write a report or fill in a worksheet.”
•  At home children can do work that matters and has meaning. If they read a book they love they can hop online and discuss it with other people who’ve read it or publish a review for Amazon. If they want to learn something they have an unfiltered world of resources (inaccessible in many schools) at their fingertips to do so.

Parents of Generation Z have woken up and realized that the industrial model school’s of today are preparing their children for a world that no longer exists. They know that those who receive outdated, classroom-based instruction will end up with the rest of the young people Occupying Wall Street and beyond.

However, there is another option! Home educating families are onto something. The children of these families will grow up as adults who know how to take ownership of their learning and their lives. They will be empowered with the ability to attain satisfaction and success in life and career.

What are your thoughts on the current public education system? Does homeschooling sound appealing to you?

Like this post? You might also enjoy 12 Most Loving Ways to Spark Creativity in Your Child.

If you liked this article, please give it a thumbs up  in Stumbleupon. Thanks!

Featured image courtesy of  Éktor via Creative Commons.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Lisa Nielsen

Lisa Nielsen has spent more than a decade working in various capacities in the public school system as an administrator and teacher to support learning in real and innovative ways that will prepare students for success. In addition to her award winning blog TheInnovativeEducator, Ms. Nielsen’s writing is featured in places such as Huffington Post, Tech & Learning, MindShift, Leading & Learning. She is the author of the book Teaching Generation Text TeachingGenerationText.com, and has published. The Teenager’s Guide to Opting Out of School For Success, The Working Home Educator’s Guide to Success, and Fix The School, Not The Child.

468 ad
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
psmom 5 pts

A "Public School Teacher and Administer" used the phrase "have woken up". Reason #13 not to put your child in a public school.

homeschoolsteps 6 pts

I live reason 7 best. hopping off to the beach today! 

redoaklane1 6 pts

I think you have outlined some great reasons for homeschooling.  I am a homeschool mom myself.  My daughters attended public school and it was exactly as you said. 

WratchelRattleberry 6 pts

This list of reasons to homeschool are spot on. Thanks for posting them. Perhaps, though, we can avoid the accusation that students who are learning through the industrial model of education "will end up with the rest of the young people Occupying Wall Street and beyond." Instead, we can view those parents' choices to use the public school system with equanimity. We can feel feel free to have confidence in our own decisions to homeschool, while at the same practicing a non-judgemental approach to others who are doing things differently.

redoaklane1 6 pts

 WratchelRattleberry I agree with you.  I was taken aback by that sentiment.

LisaVelmerNielsen 9 pts

 WratchelRattleberry I admit it. I judge a parent when they see that school is not in the best interest of their children. Why do we think so many kids are occupying Wall Street and beyond? It is no wonder that kids are not prepared for the work force today. Preparation for the workforce has no place in the test obsessed climate of schools today and there are no bubble tests in the world of work. More and more parents are becoming informed and discovering that in many cases there are better options than public school these days.  I applaud the parent who looks into doing what is best, which might not be what is easiest, for their child.  If they feel something is not right, they should take the time to look into some other options. 

sharongreenthal 63 pts

 LisaVelmerNielsen  WratchelRattleberry It seems to me that  homeschooling parents and advocates are just about the most judgmental and self-righteous group of people I've come across on the internet. Why is it so important that everyone who believes in public school be preached to and converted to the home and/or unschooling way of life? There are plenty of kids who are fantastic and successful who go the way of public school - not damaged for life and able to function quite well as adults, thank you. Keep doing what works for you, homeschoolers - and stop denigrating and insulting those of us who believe in the public schools and would rather see them improved upon than shunned. Lisa, it amazes me that you are an employee of a public school system and yet do everything you can to call out the public schools for being essentially useless. 

LisaVelmerNielsen 9 pts

 sharongreenthal  WratchelRattleberry I've been in the system many years and have seen it take a sharp turn away from what is right or best for children. For the past two years I see school after school where teachers and school leaders are forced to do what they know is not right for children. They are afraid to speak up for fear of losing their jobs. I'm on the inside. I am an employee. Are you amazed that I am sharing what I see...What we all see... And that I am not afraid to speak up on behalf of kids? Perhaps it is different where your children go to school, but in the high-stakes testing, accountability culture of systems like the one in which I work, everyone in the know when it comes to what happens in schools, knows this is not right.  

 

You're amazed that I call out the system. I'm saddened more do not.  

MaribelFlores 5 pts

 sharongreenthal

 I agree with you partially.  I am a homeschool mom, should say new to homeschooling on my second year.  My son, now 15 years of age was falling behind in school. He has struggled since the 1st grade.  The school had him tested for ADD, ADHD, etc.  I had him tested with our  family  doctor as well. Tests were negative. Our doctors thoughts were that he was just a late bloomer, that he needed more time to understand his work.  We tried keeping him in school, but with budget cuts and classrooms with 30 or more students it was impossible.  We hired  a tutor, it helped him , but he was still falling behind in class.  And thats the reason I decided to homeschool.  Every parent has the right to raise and educate their children as they see fit, but we shouldn't look down on parents who don't choose to homeschool, or look down at our public schools.  We are part of a community and as so, we should help in anyway we can to strengthen education system for all our children. We are all resposible to help and take care of one another.  I still volunteer at our local public schools and have my oldest son volunteer as well. I praise every teacher. I pray for them. There is need for our public schools and we need to support our teachers.

sharongreenthal 63 pts

 MaribelFlores My son also had a hard time. He was diagnosed with ADD at 9 years old. The schools did a lot to help him but he ALWAYS struggled for many reasons. However, what kept him going and made him happy was the socialization, football, and feeling like he was a part of something bigger than he was. Now that he is in college he has become the good student that we always knew he would be. I do not believe public schools are perfect, but I believe that they are the best hope for the most amount of children in our country, and I agree that the schools need our support and help. Your decision to homeschool is a selfless and loving one, and I admire and respect your for it. I also appreciate the fact that you still see the need for support in your public schools.

 

My problem is not with homeschooling - its with homeschoolers who present their choice as the only choice for everyone. That's just not possible.

 sharongreenthal

 :) Well, as a homeschool mom, I'm good with all the choices. I think they are all valid depending on the individual family/child/situation. So, score one point? :)

 sharongreenthal

 She didn't say everybody needs to convert to this way of thinking. She said in the beginning that these are 12 reasons IF your child is "not finding success and happiness" in the public schools. School when you went to school is very different than what is going on now.  Yes, there are plenty of children thriving, but I welcome you to come to my district, where for every year your child is enrolled, their test scores drop, bottoming out to the point that only 28 percent of high school seniors are reading at grade level (it's even worse in the  non caucasian demographic, then it's a mere 17 percent!) So yes, 28 percent (of white kids) in my district are perhaps doing "fantastic and sucecessful", but what about the other 72 percent not doing well? What about them? Somebody needs to sound the alarm, and frankly, I'm ashamed that most of the eduacators in our district aren't standing up, aren't telling the truth, aren't fighting for real change. Bravo to Lisa for giving an  honest assessment of the climate in our public schools.

 WratchelRattleberry As a homeschooler and now widowded mother of three who finds her options to home school limited- I sincerely appreciate you not judging all those who have their children in public school.  It is not in my children's absolute best interest to be in public school, but sometimes we must do what we can to make things work.  

barbie042084 6 pts

I really did enjoy this article. Another point that we should look at is all the budget cuts that are being made across the country. So many of them are impacting the students and schools. How can a child learn all that they truly need to know with the limited budget the schools are working with?

 

Another point that I want to make is this: I was a public schooled child. I wanted to be homeschooled since I did have issues being social, being picked on, etc. Instead I got a public school education. I cannot tell you how many things I have forgotten that the school system taught me. Now, at 28 years old I am teaching myself genealogy and a couple other subjects. To say that I have learned more as a self-taught individual would be an understatement. I do better teaching myself and learning at my own pace without having to worry about falling behind and what the student next to me is doing and if they "get" the subject better than I do. I always felt that grades were a way to compare one student to the next and to determine who was bright and who was not.

 

 

thefarmerslife 13 pts

My first hands on experience with homeschool came last fall. A group of kids from Chicago got in touch with me through my blog. They ended up coming out to the farm for a day, and I just wanted to mention that these young people were incredibly organized, prepared, and most of all well behaved. When you have two mini van loads of kids middle school age and younger pull up and the boys get out and hold the doors open for the girls without being told to you know it's a good group! Here's a link to what we did that day. http://www.causematters.com/advocacy/on-the-farm-with-chicago-kids/

LisaTVT 5 pts

Interesting that "the boys: held the doors for "the girls" Kind of gender role-ish eh? How about some kids hold the doors for other kids? Or is this a group of gender conformist fundamentalist Christians?

MaribelFlores 5 pts

 LisaTVT

 Oh, brother..Here we go..  gender roleish?..lol  Is it now wrong for a boy to open a door or hold a door open for a girl. Nothing here about gender conformist. I would very much expect my son to be curtious  and wouldn't at all mind if a girl did the same, but making an issue of it, well it's just nonsense.

 LisaTVT

 What a shame that some children showed honor and respect to other children.

 LisaTVT

 So only gender conformist fundamentalist Christian men hold open doors for women?

Mama_to_six 5 pts

" I just use the county school system for a certain number of hours per day so I can work from home and earn money for our family."

So PS is the babysitter ! We choose frugal living and time with the kids over living at the bar placed by marketers.

We HS for 16 years, the kids have friends and not just those found in their particular class. They range from 65 to 3 years old.

I find the idea that public school is for interaction laughable. As stated here, only at lunch or parties were the good times found. Life does not segregate by age and I have been joyful to see how easily my six kids interact with people of all ages.

I have very active kids that I can't imagine would ever be able to sit for 6-8 hours! They, by their nature, are meant to move ,jump and run. I have had too many neighbors with kids just as active tell mine that the school wants them on ADD/ADHD drugs. The same kids in my yard that are active and curious. Not problematic just kids.

Those families with less than stellar results may be due to learning abilities. HS allows self pace without the fear of being "left back".

I went to PS and believe that had I been unschooled many more possibilities would be open for me.Not a great reason but it was because of my friends that I did not take some classes I had the opportunity to. I wanted to get classes with my friends. I don't want that for my children. When I see what they are doing I am glad they are able to follow their interests and not that of their peer group. My daughter has a unique sense of style that might not fly at school and that would be sad to repress.

I choose HS and the PS needs to be razed and rebuilt with the children in mind not corporate markets. Until then HS unschool is the best choice for us.

I just stumbled across this post and have spent more time reading the comments than the actual entry. I feel I need to add my two cents worth to the schooling/homeschooling debate. I am a product of parochial schooling. When it came time for my husband and me to decide hat we were going to do, homeschooling was not our first option; a parochial school similar to what I attended or a charter school were what we wanted. However, neither of those worked out and we ended up homeschooling.

We see now that it this is the best option for us as my almost 13-year-old son has been traveling nationally and internationally with a professional boys' choir since he was 8 years old. Being able to work schooling around his schedule has been a life saver for us all.

Others have mentioned their concern of academic and social skills. Yes, I have heard of sad stories of homeschooled kids so poorly prepared for life that they struggle. That has motivated me to make sure my kids are successful. (I also have an almost six-year-old daughter in second grade.) Each year, I spend months researching the best material that will meet their needs and interests, and I am not afraid to approach a topic from multiple view points.

For example, my son has to worker harder in math than in some of his other subjects. I have used multiple resources over the past few years, some orthodox, some unorthodox, but all with the goal of helping him achieve. Because we homeschool,I can research and find materials that will fit my son, his learning style and his needs. (BTW, I have been a classroom teacher and understand the frustrations that go with the job.)

Do I have the opinion that homeschooling should fit all? No, I do not. Not all parents have the temperament type to homeschool; in fact, I know my mom and I would have driven each other nuts had she tried to homeschool me. Our job as homeschoolers is to respect the decisions everyone must make in regards to the education of their children.

shutterbug325 5 pts

I've been homeschooling our youngest four for the past three years, and wouldn't have it any other way.

Tribe2point0 29 pts

Thanks for a well written piece that thoroughly explains many of the of the advantages homeschooled children can experience. We have chosen to homeschool and it has been and continues to be an amazing and rewarding journey.

KatherineSievers-Ortiz 5 pts

Love this, thank you for sharing. :) I keep telling myself daily that I would not give my my kids education for anything, homeschooling them is the best thing I know I can do for them and their future.

As a public school grad (K-12) and the mommy of a public school kid, I appreciate this article but do think that the statements about public school are quite generalized. Some public schools are horrible, I will not deny that...but some are good and for some kids, attending public school is the right choice. I don't think you make a blanket recommendation for all children...I homeschooled my son for a while and he HATED it, no matter how much we did to socialize with other kids (and we did things often, classes at the Y, did a homeschool coop, etc.), he missed being in a classroom and learning with other kids, we talked to him and decided that attending school would be best for him. My daughter (still preschool age), may be a different story. Her personality is so different. I think, like everything else we do as parents, that our approach to education needs to take into account the personality of our child.

Luckily, we are blessed to live in a county that has excellent schools, the technology is amazing and my son's teacher is great. The "routine" in their class involves a lot of independent learning, they have opportunities every day to learn the same concept but in a way that works best for them (reading, listening, manipulating, computers, etc.) and they interact a lot with kids in other grades and classes. I will say that, if you are going to send your kids to school, in my opinion, it's your responsibility as a parent to be as involved as possible in that school. Volunteer in the classroom, get to know the teacher well, volunteer for PTA and actually show up for the meetings, get to know the principal...sending your kids somewhere and not ever having any further contact with the school is irresponsible. I agree that the education system in our country as a whole is broken, but I also know (based on our personal experience), that you have to first, know your child well, second, know the public schools in your area well, and make the best decision for your family and don't worry about what everyone else thinks!

Um, did you read the part where she says "if your child is not finding success and happiness there."? She is not saying everyone should homeschool.

flourishandblots 5 pts

Um, did you read the part where she says, 'Parents of Generation Z have woken up and realized that the industrial model school’s of today are preparing their children for a world that no longer exists. They know that those who receive outdated, classroom-based instruction will end up with the rest of the young people Occupying Wall Street and beyond."?  Her summation indicates that public school is not the best, and homeschooling is.

Her statements about the realizations of public vs home education are true. And while public school education may be best for your son, it may not for others. Either way she did state the differences. If your son likes sitting in a classroom working on endless book reports & being taught to "the test" then that's great.Unfortunately, many schools may want more parent involvement but don't receive it which cases conflict for everyone.

We personally home educate because I DO NOT believe in state mandated testing nor do I believe children at an elementary age should be forced to sit in a seat for 6 to 8 hours a day with 30 other children. My children will NOT be discouraged from learning what their heart desires and that's an unfortunate activity that happens in a B&M school.

flourishandblots 5 pts

Wow.  Really? "If your son likes sitting in a classroom working on endless book reports & being taught to "the test" then that's great."

 

How about a little tolerance for different ideas here?  You make her son sound ridiculous, and you don't even know him.  What an unkind thing to say to another parent.  You have very strong beliefs about homeschooling, and I think that's wonderful, but don't berate and put down others who CHOOSE to send their children to public school.

:) My heavenly word. I was in a school such as this and really enjoyed it and felt I got a pretty good education most of the time. We do homeschool now, but it's a shame, an absolute shame to have some behave as you are right now.

This is great, for those who are wealthy enough to have one stay-at-home parent. For the rest of us, we have to work on improving public schools, not just pull our kids out and leave them to the poorest among us.

Sue5 8 pts

You might be surprised that there are homeschooling families with both parents working. Yes, they usually have to have a pretty impressive support system as well as some flexibility in at least one of the careers.But as for us, we simply readjusted our priorities. We decided that a lot of things were simply options we weren't going to have...big vacations, a boat, the new cars, great clothes. Over time, I did add on part time work when we needed more money. But, like I said, when you shift your priorities, you can pretty much do whatever you really want to do.

flourishandblots 5 pts

 Sue5 How can I just "shift my priorities" when I work a rigid schedule of 8-5, M-F?  We don't have big vacations, a boat, a new car or great clothes and we still need to have two incomes for now.  Shifting my priorities won't change my job situation....

Sue5 8 pts

 flourishandblots Sorry I didn't see this before. But I would just suggest that you are not trapped. If you want something different, you will find a way to get it.  And maybe that job won't work with homeschooling. That doesn't mean that the idea of homeschooling has to go away. Maybe you need a different job. I know that sounds like a huge jump, and before you tell me all the reasons that's a stupid suggestion, I just want to point out that it's not IMPOSSIBLE.  I have no idea what your job or your family or your life looks like. But I believe (100%) that no one is without options. If you want to stay where you are and complain that you have no choices, you can do that. But it isn't really true. Everyone can choose something different - whenever you're brave enough to look for solutions.Good luck to you. 

It is possible to work and still homeschool. My husband works full time during the week and I work part time evenings and weekends.

Krystle 5 pts

I'm a single mom and I homeschool. It's hard, but it's worth it for me.

We ar a military family with 4 children and make under $30K gross income and since we are still able to save a considerable amount each month I am sure we could survive comfortably on less . I don't think anyone would call us "wealthy". We sacrifice what most people would call "necessities" but we have no debt and are very happy with being "poor" in order to homeschool.

LisaVelmerNielsen 9 pts

Parents in many #homeschooling families work. I feature such families as well as advice for how to do so successfully in my "Working home educator's guide to success" (http://store.payloadz.com/go?id=985801). Of particular interest might be the introduction by a single, working home educating mom.

AshleyPittman 6 pts

I went to public school and although it wasn't a great district and we had far less educational gain than some better districts, it was a great experience. The socialization was very beneficial, however the drama and bullies were just disgusting. I can see why some people feel home schooling is the right fit, however I think the child should be the one to make the ultimate decision. I graduated with a girl who was home schooled for years and hated it. Her mom made her do it out of control and being over protective. If I had the choice, I too would have requested to be homeschooled for the simple fact that our schools were terrible. My fondest memories of high school were lunch period and the weekend parties...not much else. As a college student, I often find classes to be challenging for the simple fact that my school only prepared the top few of the class to continue on. If parents can put in the extra effort to make sure that their children get socialization and the education they need to succeed, more power to them.

I am a Montessori Charter School founding member and parent. We are offering much of what you describe in your list- kids are working on topics they select, portfolios are developed, tests are rare, grades non-existent. We feel so fortunate.

@Amy Bowers -One of the most fabulous educators I know of is my unschooling friend, who is doing an awesome job following the child(ren) and deepening their experience and understanding of topics that interest them. Her kids participate in real-world activities which build competency and enliven discussions about the math or physics or language inherent in the activities.

Hats off to the determined and engaging public school teacher, the innovative charter schools, and to the homeschooling and unschooling parents out there. Loving kids is priority one. Educating them is a critical extension of that love.

However we teach kids, I hope we can create environments where their natural intelligence and spirit is honored rather than subjugated to the need to keep quiet, maintain order, and score a certain way on a certain test.

Great post, I also did a post like this! I often go back and re-read my post when I am feeling demotivated and it reminds me of all the good stuff

http://mother-mel.blogspot.com/2011/11/40-reasons-why-i-homeschool-my-children.html

wonderful article! Thank you for validating all of us who are "uncertified to teach". I have been on this journey of home education for 10 years. I have graduated 2, both receiving nice scholarship packages. The first received money based on talent (which she refined during "school hours"), the second based on a high ACT score. My #3 child is 16 and will soon begin taking community college classes. #4 is 13 yo and figuring out what he likes and doesn't like to do with his time. Which brings me to the point of my response. Reason #13: High school is waste of precious time. Why do we make children take classes in high school, repeat them in college, and then PAY for the privledge to do so? Most of the General Ed. courses cover the same basic information; the only differnce is that it takes a semster rather than an entire academic year. The teen years are a limited time of rapid growth; mentally, spiritual, physically, emotionally. Let's free them from the bricks and mortar walls that imprison them, and allow them to practice being an adult in the REAL world. Now THAT would be education reform.

Sue5 8 pts

I did a little comparison of School or Homeschool if anyone is interested. We've done both.http://ll-unschooling.blogspot.com/2012/01/school-or-home.html

Yayyypublicschool 5 pts

The various grammatical errors in this are ridiculous. Way to lose credibility. You should probably proof read before you post. (I learned that in public school.)

Justanothermom 10 pts

Yayyypublicschool I doubt that you have read many internet comments written by a currently public schooled child. Grammar is practically non-existent in today's Internet Society.

I was also public schooled and am presently homeschooling my 3 children. While public school worked out "okay" for me, it definitely didn't inspire me. AT ALL. In fact,the only good memories I have of high school are the after school clubs and the weekend parties. My kids are doing just fine without the 7-8 hours of education outside of the home. There are a lot of advantages to P.S. There are a lot of advantages to homeschooling. To try and claim that one or the other is perfect is ridiculous. But when people get their panties in a bunch over a topic that is obviously NOT perfect is a waste of time. Public school failed my sons. It would have failed my daughter. It didn't do a lot for me, either. So far, I'm not seeing how my kids are missing out on anything.

I know that any parent who can sit down with their children for 1-2 hours of homework each day, after that child has been being "educated" for 7 hours at school, has the ability to homeschool. Consider homeschooling homework before exhaustion.

She probably did too.""I learned that in public school"

Yayyypublicschool

Sue5 8 pts

Yayyypublicschool
So TYPICAL that in an important discussion, the Pro-public school person wants to nitpick on grammar instead of focus on the actual content. I guess the shallow end of the pool is more comfortable for some people.
Just reminds me of my school days.

flourishandblots 5 pts

 Yayyypublicschool Was that really necessary? 

The main issue is that teachers (especially at the high school level where students are placed based on standardized test scores, reading level, and the presence of a disability) are placed in various levels of classes. The teachers assume that since students aren't "Honors" material, they don't care about school or will put in the time to work on individual assignments if given the chance. There is so much judgement. A child may struggle with spelling, but have amazing literary analysis skills yet is placed in a lower level class and is thus bored due to the lackluster reading material. And thus the downward spiral continues.